2013 Policy Assessment

Camden Conference > 2013 Conference > 2013 Study Guide > 2013 Policy Assessment

Introduction

All nations, including our own, develop foreign policies — long- and short-term — that reflect their goals and guide their behavior in regard to other nations or regions they deem important to their national interests. This selection of video clips from 2013 Conference speakers explores recent events in the Middle East and related US policy from a variety of perspectives, with topics including: current US policies in the region, the historical development of these policies, consideration of policy successes and failures, lessons learned from each, and a way forward for US policy makers in the 21st century.

In assessing US foreign policy, consider also the significance of strategy. Although a clear goal may well exist in policy, implementation of action steps to achieve that goal may or may not succeed. In this realm of uncertainty between stated goals and effective implementation of action steps, strategy is tested.

In this sense, strategy reflects the ever-changing dynamic of working toward stated policy goals through diplomatic and military action. Strategy can change as events unfold, whereas policy goals usually remain constant. Your students should consider this issue by asking themselves: What factors need to be considered in developing strategy? What are the challenges to implementation of that strategy? What developments on the ground or in dialogue might lead to a change in policy goals?

Please review the video clips below to learn more about the interplay of policy and strategy.

Policy Assessment Video Links

Tribes as Limiting Factors, Robin Wright

Change in the Arab World, Marwan Muasher

Democratic Norms in the Middle East, Marwan Muasher

Role for the United States to Effect Change, Marwan Muasher

History of Control, Joshua Landis

Recent US Policy, Joshua Landis

Current Policy Dilemma, Joshua Landis

Defines the Middle Eastern Cold War, Gregory Gause

The Crescent of Weakness, Gregory Gause

The United States and Proliferation of the Middle Eastern Cold War, Gregory Gause

The Balance of Power in the Middle East, Gregory Gause

Arab Spring or Islamic Revolution, Gregory Gause

The Saudi’s Push Back to Maintain Their Sphere of Influence, Gregory Gause

Syria and the Balance of Power in the Middle East, Gregory Gause

Is History Repeating Itself, Gregory Gause

Preamble – Five Aspects of the Policy Considerations, Shai Feldman

Would a Military Strike Against Iran Result in Regional Conflict, Shai Feldman

How Would the Obama Administration Respond, Shai Feldman

Concluding Remarks, Shai Feldman

US Policy Toward Iran, Mousavian

NPT, Mousavian

Dual Policy Followed by West, Mousavian

Militarization of US Policy, Larry Pope

Role of Foreign Service, Larry Pope

Obama Strategy, Larry Pope

Hillary Clinton’s Role, Larry Pope

 

Study Guide Questions for Policy Assessment

1. How is US economic policy modifying our relationship with the Middle East?

2. What is policy and how is it developed and applied?

3. What ideas or values shape policy goals?

4. To what extent does strategy fulfill policy goals?

5. How does US economic policy treat our different relationships in the Middle East?